Choosing a sperm donor is one of the most meaningful decisions a same-sex couple will make on their path to parenthood. The process combines practical medical considerations with deeply personal values around identity, genetics, and what you want your child to know about their origins. Modern sperm banks offer unprecedented levels of donor information, making informed choice more accessible than ever before.
Medical and Genetic Screening Standards
Reputable sperm banks conduct extensive medical screening before accepting donors, including full genetic carrier screening for 200–500+ conditions, infectious disease testing (HIV, hepatitis B and C, CMV, HTLV), and semen analysis parameters. The FDA requires quarantine and repeat testing for anonymous donors, and the ASRM sets standards that most US banks follow. Always verify that a donor has passed cystic fibrosis carrier screening, spinal muscular atrophy screening, and chromosomal analysis at minimum. Donors are typically retested every 6 months during active donation.
Carrier screening tells you whether a donor carries recessive genetic variants that could result in disease if combined with a carrier egg. If one birth parent is a known carrier for a specific condition, choosing a donor who is not a carrier for that same condition virtually eliminates risk of an affected child. Some banks offer expanded carrier screening matching, which cross-references your carrier status with donor status automatically. This medical due diligence is one area where working with an established bank pays significant dividends.
Open-ID vs. Anonymous Donors
Open-ID donors agree to have their identifying information released to donor-conceived children who request it at age 18. Research from donor-conceived adults, including studies published in the journal Human Reproduction, consistently shows that access to genetic and identity information supports psychological well-being and identity development. The LGBTQ+ family-building community has broadly shifted toward recommending open-ID donors for this reason. As of 2024, several countries including the UK, Australia, and Canada have banned anonymous donation entirely.
Anonymous donors remain available at most US banks but are an increasingly contested option. Some anonymous donors have been identified through consumer DNA databases like 23andMe regardless of bank policy, meaning true anonymity is no longer guaranteed in the genomic era. Having an honest family narrative about donor conception is now considered best practice in pediatric psychology and reproductive ethics. Choosing an open-ID donor aligns your child’s future access to information with the transparency that LGBTQ+ families often already embrace in their family storytelling.
Matching Donor Traits to Your Family
Many couples consider physical traits like height, eye color, hair texture, and ethnicity when selecting a donor — particularly when one partner’s genetics will not contribute to the pregnancy. This is entirely personal and there is no right or wrong approach. Some couples choose a donor who resembles the non-carrying or non-biological parent to create a sense of visual family connection. Others prioritize ethnicity matching for cultural continuity or health risk awareness, while still others care most about personality profiles and life values.
Sperm bank profiles now commonly include childhood photos, adult silhouettes, audio interviews, staff impressions, and personality assessments. Some banks partner with facial-recognition technology that can suggest donors with similar features to a submitted photo. Extended profiles may include handwritten essays, SAT/ACT scores, and detailed family health history going back three generations. Taking time to read full donor profiles aloud together, and discussing what resonates emotionally, is a process many couples find clarifying and even meaningful.
Practical Logistics of Ordering Donor Sperm
Most banks require a signed physician or midwife order to ship sperm to a clinical address, or allow direct-to-consumer shipping to a home address in many US states. Vials are shipped in liquid nitrogen dry shippers that maintain temperature for 5–7 days. Plan to order 2–4 vials per cycle and purchase or rent a storage tank if you want to bank multiple vials. Sperm storage fees typically run $300–$600 per year, and many couples buy 5–10 vials upfront to lock in donor availability before a popular donor sells out.
Before placing a large order, call the bank directly to confirm the donor is still active and has sufficient inventory for your full family plan — including potential sibling pregnancies. Some couples also check the Donor Sibling Registry (DSR) to see how many families are already connected to a given donor, which can inform decisions about openness and sibling relationships for donor-conceived children. Shipping costs typically run $150–$300 per shipment, so consolidating vials in a single order saves money. Check your bank’s return and storage policy carefully before purchasing.
For a complete at-home insemination solution, the MakeAmom Cryobaby Kit includes everything you need for a properly timed, sterile ICI cycle. For a complete at-home insemination solution, the MakeAmom Babymaker Kit includes everything you need for a properly timed, sterile ICI cycle.
Further reading across our network: HomeInsemination.gay · IntracervicalInsemination.org · IntracervicalInsemination.com
This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider before making decisions about your fertility care.
