Your cart is currently empty!
The Circus Is Closing, And I’m Not Upset
The announcement from the owners of Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus about their impending closure in May marks the end of an era that lasted 146 years. Reactions vary from shock to nostalgia, and even cheers of joy. But personally, I found myself pondering, why did it take so long?
Like many changes, the circus’s closure carries complexities and consequences. There will be job losses for those who have dedicated their lives to this circus culture, and animals will need new homes. An American tradition is fading away. However, considering the dark underbelly of this “tradition,” it’s high time for a farewell.
Many of us have cherished memories of the circus, with vibrant images of colorful trains arriving in town, packed with fascinating performers and magnificent animals that enchanted our innocent minds. We were blissfully unaware of the unsettling truths lurking behind the curtain—and many of us chose to stay that way. But deep down, an inkling of discomfort was there; perhaps it was the sight of a bullhook, or the first time we witnessed an animal being struck. Maybe it was the cramped, filthy cages or the sight of an elephant aimlessly circling around. Eventually, we started to connect the dots, spurred by books like Water for Elephants or The One and Only Ivan, or news stories revealing the tragic fate of animals like Kenny, a young Asian elephant who died while touring with Ringling in 1998. Investigations into animal cruelty uncovered heartbreaking truths, including illness, separation of baby elephants from their mothers, and prolonged confinement.
As an animal lover who treats my pets like family, I’ve never been a circus aficionado. In our home, we avoid harming even the smallest creatures; I once let a mouse roam free for weeks while trying every humane method to catch it. My few visits to the circus as a child were filled with cotton candy and awe at the acrobats, yet as an adult, my unease grew. Still, I couldn’t resist taking my son, who delighted in riding elephants and watching tigers perform just feet away. I tried to ignore the unsettling feeling that gnawed at me.
The circus has faced criticism for years over its questionable treatment of animals. While many—including myself—turned a blind eye to the truth for too long, it became increasingly difficult to ignore the stories of animal suffering. “We didn’t know any better,” said Lisa Green, president of Compassionate Creatures International. “Now, we do. People are more informed and can recognize suffering in other species. They don’t want to witness animals in distress for mere entertainment.”
For some, the circus’s closure may evoke bittersweet feelings, but for me, it’s overwhelmingly a cause for celebration. I don’t want to see animals in pain for even a moment. While the closure will impact jobs, it doesn’t have to be a zero-sum game. We can advocate for animal welfare while also supporting the livelihoods of the workers involved. There are plenty of ways to enjoy time with family and appreciate animals without compromising their well-being. Consider visiting animal sanctuaries or checking out Cirque du Soleil instead. Spend a day volunteering at a local shelter or adopt an endangered species through the World Wildlife Fund.
We can extend kindness to both humans and animals; it’s not an either-or dilemma. After all, we are all part of the animal kingdom. So, while some might indulge in nostalgia for what some have dubbed the “greatest show on earth,” I’m genuinely relieved—and yes, even joyful—that the curtain is finally closing on this act. And don’t even get me started on those clowns.
For further insights and resources on pregnancy and home insemination, check out this excellent resource on pregnancy. If you’re interested in at-home insemination, consider exploring this informative blog post, or check out Make a Mom for authoritative information on insemination kits.
Summary
The Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus is closing, which elicits mixed emotions, but for many, including the author, it’s a welcome end to an institution associated with animal cruelty. While acknowledging the job losses, the article emphasizes the importance of animal welfare and suggests alternatives for family entertainment that do not exploit animals.