Imagine pouring your heart and soul into building your dream home, with all the necessary city permits in hand, only to find yourself embroiled in a lawsuit from your next-door neighbors. In a South Dakota neighborhood, that’s exactly the scenario playing out for a couple whose aspirations have taken a dramatic turn.
Josh and Sarah Thompson were recently ordered by a judge to “reconstruct or relocate” their newly built four-bedroom residence, which stands just seven feet away from the home of their neighbors, Mark and Linda Cooper. This ruling comes as the Thompsons’ house has been deemed a violation of the historic standards set in the McKennan Park Historic District, much to the dismay of the Coopers, who claim their natural light has been significantly obstructed.
According to USA Today, the Coopers filed a lawsuit against the Thompsons, asserting that their home blocks essential sunlight. To add to the complexity, a fire inspector’s report indicated that the Coopers could no longer use their fireplace because it now lies within ten feet of the Thompsons’ property. “The Thompsons have disrupted the character of the neighborhood,” stated Judge Michael Reynolds, who sided with the Coopers after a six-month legal deliberation.
The judge noted that the Coopers had suffered a loss in both monetary and historic value due to the proximity of the Thompsons’ home, ultimately concluding that a financial settlement would not suffice. Instead, he mandated that the Thompsons conform their residence to the neighborhood’s standards, which could mean relocating their home, reducing its height, or potentially demolishing it altogether.
Tensions between the two families had been escalating even before construction began, as the Coopers sent a cease-and-desist letter to the Thompsons, warning them of possible legal action if they proceeded. However, the Thompsons moved forward with construction, dismissing the Coopers’ concerns. “It’s frustrating to see someone build without consideration for the surrounding community,” said the Coopers’ attorney, Rachel Smith. The Coopers feel vindicated by the ruling, as it emphasizes the importance of adhering to zoning laws and historical standards for the benefit of all homeowners in Sioux Falls.
Interestingly, while the city of Sioux Falls approved the Thompsons’ building plans, it failed to apply federal guidelines for historic districts—a misstep that Judge Reynolds acknowledged as a potential negligence issue on the city’s part. As of now, it remains unclear whether the city will face any repercussions.
With the judge’s decision in hand, the Thompsons have the option to appeal and continue their fight to retain their home, which stands just a stone’s throw away from their neighbors. For those interested in exploring family-building resources, check out this excellent resource for pregnancy and home insemination.
In summary, the legal drama around the Thompsons’ dream home highlights the challenges that arise when new constructions clash with established neighborhood standards. The outcome could reshape not just their future but also the dynamics of community living in historic districts.