Every autumn, as summer fades into fall, the familiar Halloween costume debates ignite, especially with the rise of social media. Once October rolls around, countless individuals begin curating costumes that often invoke concern among culturally aware individuals: Geisha, Indian Princess, Sugar Skull-wearer. The conversation quickly evolves into a clash of viewpoints.
On one side are the advocates for cultural sensitivity, who assert that culture should not be reduced to a costume. In the opposing corner are those who, despite their good intentions to appreciate cultures, often miss the mark. Justifications for their choices range from “I’m channeling Pocahontas” to the dismissive “It’s just a costume!” and the ever-common “I’m not appropriating; I’m appreciating.” To borrow a line from a famous movie: “You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.”
Cultural appropriation is a term that has become increasingly contentious, especially among those who feel that political correctness has gone too far. Discussions about the implications of getting a dreamcatcher tattoo or the ethics of buying “cultural artifacts” from stores like Urban Outfitters often elicit defensive reactions, reminiscent of a politician caught off guard by tough questions.
So, how can one genuinely appreciate other cultures without causing offense? Don’t worry, you’re not confined to bland attire; there are ways to celebrate diversity respectfully. Here are three essential steps to appreciate without appropriating:
- Support the Source
At its core, cultural appropriation involves capitalizing on cultures that are not your own. If you admire African jewelry, seek it out directly from artisans or fair-trade businesses. Invest in the livelihoods of the craftspeople whose work you admire. This approach not only supports ethical practices but also transforms appropriation into genuine appreciation. Brands eager to showcase diverse designs could collaborate with designers from the respective cultures, acknowledging their contributions in marketing materials. This way, appreciation flourishes. - Educate Yourself
Do you have a fondness for dreamcatchers? That’s wonderful! But do you know their origin among the Ojibwe people? This isn’t just an “Indian” thing. Take the time to learn about the cultural significance behind what you admire. When purchasing, always buy from authentic sources, not generic shops. Refrain from decorating spaces with themes that reduce rich cultures to mere aesthetics. Instead, introspect on why you’re drawn to these motifs. Often, such impulses stem from stereotypes shaped by a society that has romanticized and exoticized marginalized communities. - Appreciate, Don’t Take
Genuine appreciation should never equate to entitlement. You can admire something without assuming ownership. For instance, if you admire the beauty of another’s hairstyle, express that admiration verbally but refrain from touching. If you’re in a position to influence hiring, ensure inclusivity by hiring individuals from diverse backgrounds, rather than excluding them based on their natural appearance.
In summary, while it’s commendable to appreciate other cultures, it’s vital to approach this appreciation with knowledge and respect. Your attempts to engage with cultural practices may seem harmless, yet they can carry echoes of colonialism and exploitation. Instead of adopting cultural elements superficially, commit to understanding and supporting the communities behind them. Strive for equity and justice in your own community, and invest time in learning about your heritage as well, respecting its unique significance.
For more insightful discussions, check out our post on sample page about navigating cultural appreciation. Additionally, Make a Mom offers valuable resources on the fertility journey. For those navigating the complexities of fertility and insurance, UCSF’s FAQ provides excellent guidance.