People often express their strong opinions when confronted with ideas they don’t support, especially regarding transgender identities. Those who oppose transgender rights and our right to safety and inclusion frequently voice their disapproval of my identity as a “lifestyle choice.” They often rely on religious beliefs to justify a lack of compassion towards transgender individuals, denying us essential services and humane treatment.
The refusal to acknowledge our existence only perpetuates ignorance. My experiences and truth as a transgender person are disregarded by those who cling to their outdated beliefs, unwilling to accept the reality of our lives. But what drives this willful ignorance to transform into fear, disgust, and even violence? Why does the presence of transgender individuals seem so threatening to some?
It’s crucial to state: if a transgender person is simply trying to live their life without causing harm, they should not be seen as a threat. Unfortunately, in 42 states, the gay/trans panic defense still exists, allowing perpetrators of violence to blame their victims based on their gender identity or sexual orientation, although some states are working to change this.
People often feel uncomfortable when challenged to expand their understanding of gender beyond traditional norms. Research from St. Louis University shows that while gender nonconforming individuals may face judgment, transgender individuals often evoke even stronger reactions. Many cling to the belief that one’s biological sex dictates their gender, a notion that intersex and transgender people challenge. Our bodies do not define our identities.
For many cisgender people, the presence of transgender individuals can feel like a threat to their own identity. They often operate under the misconception that gender is strictly binary, and the existence of nonbinary people like myself complicates their understanding. When faced with someone who defies their rigid definitions of gender, confusion and hostility can arise, leading to what psychologists term “distinctiveness threat.” This theory posits that when the boundaries of group identities shift, individuals may feel their own self-concept is at risk.
For example, if I or another trans masculine person is perceived as a man despite being assigned female at birth, it can trigger defensiveness in cisgender men. This reaction stems from an insecurity about their own identity, especially if they believe that gender is strictly determined by anatomy. I have encountered situations where the shift in someone’s perception of my gender led to defensiveness or even aggression, leaving me feeling vulnerable and on edge. Public spaces, including transportation, gas stations, and restrooms, often heighten my anxiety, as these are common sites of policing and misunderstanding.
The more rigidly someone holds onto the idea that gender is binary and linked to biological sex, the more threatening they may perceive transgender people to be. We can combat this fear through increased representation of transgender individuals, diverse literature, and teaching children about healthy gender expression. Challenging traditional gender roles and fostering understanding of gender fluidity are essential steps toward building acceptance.
Cisgender individuals must recognize that my identity should not be a source of discomfort for them, especially when over 25% of transgender people have faced bias-driven violence. My identity cannot be validated if those around me prioritize their own feelings of safety over my existence.
For more insights on this topic, you can explore our other blog post at intracervicalinsemination.com. Additionally, if you’re interested in home insemination, check out Make A Mom for expert guidance, and for further reading on family-building options, Resolve provides excellent resources.
In summary, the existence of transgender individuals challenges outdated beliefs about gender and identity. Acknowledging and respecting our identities is crucial for fostering understanding and acceptance in society.