Menume time
I Own Several Pairs of the Must-Have Flats Everyone Loves — And Yes, They’re Worth Every Penny!
By Emily Carter
Updated: September 2, 2021
Originally Published: February 26, 2021
So, you’re on the hunt for a no-nonsense review of Rothy’s flats, huh? I totally get it. At $125 or more, you want to make sure that you’re investing in something worthwhile, especially when it comes to footwear. I’m all about products that deliver on their promises—especially when they’re on the pricier side. Let me set the record straight: Rothy’s flats are a solid A++. I adore my Rothy’s so much that I sometimes joke about wanting to marry them instead of my husband. Seriously, I wish I had discovered these sooner because no other flat or slip-on shoe compares.
Now, here’s why you should take my word for it, treat yourself, and buy a pair of Rothy’s as a fabulous gift for your feet (and your wardrobe). You’ll be looking and feeling fabulous.
Let’s get one thing clear: Flats have been my footwear of choice since high school, so I consider myself pretty knowledgeable about them. A classic black pair of flats is timeless, and I’ll stand by that until the end of my days (and yes, when that day comes, you can bury me in my beloved flats). Over the past 15 years, I’ve tried nearly every type of flat imaginable, from ballet flats to loafers and even flashy glitter ones. But then, in my late 20s, my feet started to protest. Wearing uncomfortable shoes for long hours at work became a challenge.
While flats are generally comfy, I knew I needed an upgrade. About two years ago, after getting a new job and promotion, I finally caved after seeing countless ads for Rothy’s on Instagram. This purchase was unlike many others I’d made on social media—I didn’t regret it one bit. These shoes feel like little clouds embracing my feet. Just so you know, the vibrant red ones I own are called The Point in Flame.
My first pair was The Point flats in Black Solid (of course). The material is a unique woven thread made from recycled water bottles, and the insoles are crafted from bio-based castor oil and other recycled materials. Plus, the fabric feels luxurious because it incorporates sustainably-sourced Merino wool from Australia. So yes, when you splurge on $125+ flats, you’re getting shoes that are not only super comfy and stylish but are also environmentally friendly.
Another fantastic feature of Rothy’s is that they are completely machine washable without losing their shape or style. If you wear a pair of shoes often, they can become a bit…aromatic. This is especially true in warm climates or sticky summers. You know that awkward moment when you had to take off your Toms in front of friends? Not with Rothy’s! They’re breathable too. I’ve had mine for two years now and haven’t needed to wash them once—they smell great, and so do my feet, in case you were wondering.
If you’re all about bold colors and patterns, Rothy’s has an array of options, along with several styles beyond the ones I own. They offer The Flat (rounded toes), The Loafer (self-explanatory), The Mary Jane (pointed flat with an adorable bow), The Square (slightly squared off toe), and The Point (the ones I’m showcasing). They’ve also expanded to include sneakers and boots, which our shopping editor recently reviewed—stay tuned for that. The sneakers (The Lace-Up, The Sneaker, The Ankle Boot, and The Chelsea) are also washable. Plus, if you love flip-flops, they have a pair aptly named The Flip Flop.
But don’t just take my word for it. My friends, Lisa and Mia, who are also part of our team, recently tried Rothy’s and now they’re equally obsessed.
Lisa shared, “I have wide, short feet (like duck flippers), and pointy flats usually pinch my toes. But Rothy’s The Point shoes are adorable, so I gave them a shot. Wow! The stretchy material molds perfectly to my feet and the V-shaped opening elongates my toes, making them look less gnome-like. The Loafers are just as amazing, and I adore the classic look.”
Mia chimed in, “I generally dislike wearing shoes without socks, but these are breathable enough to wear barefoot. And can we talk about those colors? The rose and navy double stitch on The Point and the bright cornflower blue on The Loafers are perfect for spring. As a mom with a toddler, they’re so easy to wear, and the fact that they’re washable is a miracle. When I do go out, I want to look put together without sacrificing comfort.”
As for Amanda, she added, “These are among the most comfortable shoes I’ve had in ages. I love wearing white and cream shoes because they match everything, but they usually get dirty quickly. Knowing that Rothy’s are machine washable is a game-changer.”
If you’ve made it this far, I hope you’re convinced. Go ahead, treat yourself. You can thank me later!
Summary:
This review dives into the much-praised Rothy’s flats, highlighting their comfort, eco-friendly materials, and stylish design. With a variety of styles and colors, Rothy’s has something for everyone. The shoes are machine washable, making them practical for everyday use. If you’re considering a pair, this review suggests they are definitely worth the investment.