Can We Create a Better Kind of Family?

happy pregnant womanartificial insemination kit for humans

Life’s most profound wounds often come from unexpected places. Just last night, as I drove down my street at twilight, I witnessed the day’s colors fading into deep blue, reminiscent of melting sorbet. My neighbor, a friendly woman in her early sixties, was hosting a family gathering. Cars crowded the street and filled her freshly repaired driveway. Her children and their partners streamed in, carrying dishes of potato salad, berry trifles, and other home-cooked delights. Laughter echoed as grandkids chased their terrier, darting across my lawn and back into my neighbor’s yard, squeezing through the gate. The aroma of barbecue wafted through the air, and I felt a twinge of longing within me.

This neighbor lives close to her vibrant, sprawling family — not just children and grandchildren, but also her parents, aunts, and uncles. After losing her husband, she moved from the South to be near them, relishing the joy of hosting holiday gatherings. Family members drop by regularly, turning her home into a hub of activity. I often see the Little Tikes car parked outside, or catch the scent of brownies baking, indicating the grandkids are visiting. There’s a seamless flow between their homes, a closeness born from years of shared intimacy — a comfort I haven’t felt in a long time.

That evening, my home felt eerily silent. Just my husband, our daughter, and me. We are a happy little family, but I sometimes wonder: wouldn’t it be nice to have an extended family we actually enjoyed spending time with?

Families of origin can be complex, and there’s still not enough discussion about the trauma some endure from those who are supposed to love them. Adults often distance themselves from their parents for various reasons, though few openly admit it due to societal stigma. We establish boundaries to protect ourselves and our children — brave acts, yet in a world where the nuclear family is often seen as the ideal, disconnecting from your family can feel shameful. It raises the question: how many of us feel isolated in our experiences?

Growing up, I was often told that “blood is thicker than water,” a saying used to gloss over our familial strife. Despite our tensions and resentments, we were discouraged from discussing our pain with anyone — friends, teachers, or therapists. This coercion narrows our perspective, fostering unhealthy dependence on those who may not be safe.

My husband’s family similarly avoided uncomfortable conversations, ignoring individual pain for the sake of collective harmony. When our daughter was born, I vowed to prioritize the family we built together, cherishing her individuality even if it meant distancing ourselves from our origins.

We moved away from my husband’s family, and with that, expectations mounted. We were expected to attend every event — first communions, Sunday dinners, anniversaries, holidays — which often left us feeling drained. When we chose to stay home, we faced subtle accusations of not valuing family. I wanted to clarify that we did value family, but our small unit took precedence over the demands of a large extended family. Even when we did attend, whispers like “Oh, they’re here?” made us feel like outsiders.

I reassured myself that we could create our own family. My friends know my dreams, my secrets. When our family faced illness last fall, they brought us meals, sent toys for my daughter. My husband’s siblings didn’t check in during our recovery. My friends remember our important dates and visit as often as we do, fostering a mutual give-and-take that feels supportive. We’ve labeled them as our chosen family, even giving them titles like “aunt” and “uncle” to solidify those bonds.

However, over the past couple of years, it seems many of us have retreated inward, driven by isolation and anxiety. We travel less, focusing on day-to-day survival. This often leads to a gradual fading of friendships, especially with those who maintain strong ties to their families. We become like ghosts during holidays, our homes feeling emptier than our neighbors’. While I cherish my small family and the friends I have, the connection isn’t always perfect. Still, I’m committed to nurturing these relationships so we can be our most authentic selves.

What I wish for myself and others in similar situations is a community and language around this sense of rootlessness. Many of us seek the benefits of healthy family structures — unconditional love, shared history, comfort — even if they feel unattainable within our original families. They tell us that “family is everything,” and while I agree, it’s time to broaden our definition of family.

I hope that as my daughter grows, she’ll want to spend time with us after she leaves home, even as she builds her own family. I dream of welcoming her and her chosen ones into our home, just like my neighbor does. But I understand that’s not a guarantee. Despite my efforts, I can’t predict how we might inadvertently let her down. I promise to listen and mend what’s broken, but it may not suffice. If we can’t provide her with the relationships she needs, I hope she finds those connections elsewhere, with people who can love her as she deserves. The lesson I want to impart is that while we may not be able to change our familial circumstances, we can learn to navigate them in a way that honors who we truly are.

If you’re interested in exploring more about family dynamics, check out this insightful article on building chosen families. For those interested in improving fertility, Make a Mom offers valuable resources. Additionally, Science Daily provides excellent insights into pregnancy and home insemination.

Search Queries:

In summary, navigating family dynamics can be challenging, particularly when it comes to finding comfort and connection in a world that often prioritizes traditional family structures. Many individuals feel unmoored, seeking community and understanding as they redefine what family means to them. Embracing the idea of chosen families can provide support and fulfillment, even when biological ties are strained.