As a high school educator, I can confidently say that today’s educational landscape is heavily influenced by research and data. We assess student progress through formative assessments (to gauge learning along the way) and summative assessments (to evaluate overall understanding). We analyze past and present test scores and delve into what studies reveal about effective teaching methods. We’re continually reminded that our approaches should be grounded in research and data.
But when it comes to recess, many schools conveniently overlook the evidence. Instead of recognizing recess as an essential—indeed, vital—component of a student’s daily routine, some institutions treat it as a privilege for well-behaved students. They wield recess as a punishment tool, withholding it for misbehavior or incomplete assignments.
As parents, we often accept this practice, recalling our own experiences of losing recess for talking too much or not finishing our work. I remember those days in Mrs. Jenkins’s fourth-grade class, spending recess writing, “I will not distract others” until my hand felt like it might fall off. Sure, I survived, but should we really subject today’s kids to the same fate? The reality is that while we often had multiple recess periods, many children today are lucky to get just 20 minutes of playtime.
Research supports the importance of recess. The American Academy of Pediatrics emphasizes that it plays a critical role in child development, positively affecting emotional, social, physical, and academic growth. They argue that recess should not be withheld for punitive or academic reasons. Simply put, children need that time to recharge, and taking it away as a punishment is counterproductive.
Recess isn’t a reward or a privilege to be earned; it’s a necessity. Removing it from a child’s day is as nonsensical as taking away math or reading. It doesn’t foster better behavior or academic performance. So why do schools continue this outdated practice?
One reason might be that withholding recess appears to be a quick fix for managing disruptive behavior. However, research indicates that punishing students often fails to yield lasting behavioral changes. In fact, kids need recess to unwind, socialize, and release pent-up energy, which ultimately helps them focus better in class.
Another factor could be that teachers feel pressed for time and lack creative alternatives for discipline. While teachers are often left feeling powerless, there are various strategies to encourage better behavior without sacrificing recess.
For real change to happen, we need to advocate for updated policies at both state and federal levels to ensure children receive adequate recess time throughout their school day. Collaboration between administrators and educators is crucial to develop alternative discipline methods that don’t compromise essential playtime.
Moreover, communication with parents is vital. When parents are informed about classroom expectations and their child’s performance, they can assist in reinforcing positive behaviors at home. Taking away recess is unlikely to achieve the desired results, but perhaps limiting screen time could have more of an impact.
Childhood is fleeting, and the amount of time children spend playing has diminished significantly over the years. Recent trends in education have led many schools to severely limit, or even eliminate, recess altogether. This is unjust and detrimental to children’s well-being. Restoring recess to its rightful place in education may take time, but we must first acknowledge that it isn’t just a reward for good behavior.
For more insights on home insemination and related topics, check out our other blog posts, including this one linked here, and visit Make a Mom for expert guidance. If you’re exploring pregnancy options, Parents.com offers an excellent resource to get you started.
Summary:
Recess is an essential part of child development and should not be used as a punishment in schools. Research indicates that withholding recess can negatively impact students’ emotional and academic growth. Schools need to prioritize playtime and seek alternative disciplinary methods to support healthy development.