Individualism is a Fallacy: We All Depend on Each Other

happy babyartificial insemination kit for humans

In contemporary discussions, a prevalent narrative among certain right-leaning conservatives is the notion of absolute “freedom” and “self-sufficiency.” They often echo sentiments like “Just focus on yourself, and I’ll handle my own affairs!” or “To achieve success, you must rely solely on your own efforts!” This rhetoric suggests that their accomplishments are solely due to their own determination and hard work.

However, when we examine the statistics, it becomes clear that such claims are misleading. Data reveals that recipients of government assistance are fairly evenly distributed among both Democrats and Republicans. In fact, conservatives frequently advocate for corporate tax breaks and government bailouts during economic downturns, believing these financial aids will eventually benefit everyone through a “trickle-down” effect—which is often a false assumption. Yet, they continue to criticize liberals as merely seeking a free ride.

The Illusion of Complete Self-Sufficiency

The belief in total self-reliance is fundamentally flawed. It’s virtually impossible for anyone to be entirely self-sufficient. Even those who choose to live in communes are interdependent, taking on specific roles to meet the needs of their community.

Historically, human survival has depended on cooperation. Our ancestors thrived due to their ability to work together. For instance, archaeological findings from 36,000 years ago show that early humans cared for injured members of their community—evidence that other species lack. A broken bone, which might spell doom for an animal, was treated and healed in a human context, showcasing our innate desire to support the vulnerable.

Throughout history, orphaned children have found new families, communities have banded together to care for the elderly, and hunting parties shared their bounty with everyone, not just those who made the kill. Even modern public health measures, like quarantines, rely on collective action.

We Continue to Depend on Each Other

In today’s society, we still function as a collective, aiming to provide basic needs—shelter, food, healthcare, and education—for all. The government’s role in ensuring these essentials is widely accepted, whether through public education, infrastructure, or social security. While debates about the extent of this safety net are valid, the right’s portrayal of total self-sufficiency serves merely to label others as “moochers.”

Ironically, many conservatives support programs like social security and public education, despite their rhetoric about individual responsibility. If self-reliance were the ideal, why should anyone rely on government assistance for retirement or education?

When the topic of nationalized healthcare arises, many react negatively, despite the fact that their current insurance models already involve shared costs among individuals.

The Reality of Our Interdependence

As highlighted by social media influencers, we inherently rely on others daily. Unless one chooses to live entirely off the grid—creating their own resources and managing all their needs independently—they are part of a complex interdependent system. From safe roadways to public education, our quality of life is enhanced by communal contributions.

In fact, the high standard of living in developed nations is largely due to government support and cooperation, a fact that is often overlooked in the U.S.

So, as we discuss how to create systems that uplift everyone, let’s abandon the myth of rugged individualism. It’s a construct that simply doesn’t hold up in the face of reality.

For more information on pregnancy and home insemination, check out this excellent resource at the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. If you’re interested in exploring the nuances of home insemination, visit this related blog post.

Summary:

The belief in total self-sufficiency is a myth; humans have always relied on each other for survival. Historical evidence shows our ancestors’ cooperative nature, and modern society continues to depend on communal systems for basic needs. The narrative of individualism often ignores existing social welfare structures that benefit everyone. It’s crucial to recognize our interdependence and work towards systems that uplift all members of society.